Thursday, March 23, 2017
Podcast: Episode 124: Free Agency and Wind Sprints
from The Late Round Quarterback http://ift.tt/2n9g9nW
via IFTTT
Monday, March 20, 2017
Who Has the Best Fantasy Football Projections? 2017 Update
In prior posts, we demonstrated how to download projections from numerous sources, calculate custom projections for your league, and compare the accuracy of different sources of projections (2013, 2014, 2015, 2016). In the latest version of our annual series, we hold the forecasters accountable and see who had the most and least accurate fantasy football projections over the last 5 years.
The R Script
You can download the R script for comparing the projections from different sources here. You can download the historical projections and performance using our Projections tool.
To compare the accuracy of the projections, we use the following metrics:
- R-squared (R2) – higher is better
- Mean absolute scaled error (MASE) – lower is better
Whose Predictions Were the Best?
| Source | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | Average | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| R2 | MASE | R2 | MASE | R2 | MASE | R2 | MASE | R2 | MASE | R2 | MASE | |
| Fantasy Football Analytics: Average | .670 | .545 | .567 | .635 | .618 | .577 | .626 | .553 | .645 | .535 | .625 | .569 |
| Fantasy Football Analytics: Robust Average | .667 | .549 | .561 | .636 | .613 | .581 | .628 | .554 | .644 | .536 | .623 | .571 |
| Fantasy Football Analytics: Weighted Average | .626 | .553 | .645 | .535 | .636 | .544 | ||||||
| CBS Average | .637 | .604 | .479 | .722 | .575 | .632 | .500 | .664 | .559 | .625 | .550 | .649 |
| ESPN | .576 | .669 | .500 | .705 | .498 | .723 | .615 | .585 | .630 | .551 | .564 | .647 |
| FantasyData | .531 | .639 | .531 | .639 | ||||||||
| FantasyFootballNerd | .370 | .785 | .281 | .767 | .501 | .641 | .384 | .731 | ||||
| FantasyPros | .613 | .572 | .608 | .585 | .610 | .561 | .610 | .573 | ||||
| FantasySharks | .529 | .673 | .606 | .592 | .568 | .633 | ||||||
| FFtoday | .661 | .551 | .550 | .646 | .530 | .659 | .546 | .626 | .574 | .618 | .572 | .620 |
| NFL.com | .551 | .650 | .505 | .709 | .518 | .692 | .582 | .632 | .605 | .584 | .552 | .653 |
| WalterFootball | .472 | .713 | .431 | .724 | .483 | .718 | .462 | .718 | ||||
| Yahoo | .547 | .645 | .635 | .554 | .624 | .562 | .602 | .587 | ||||
- Fantasy Football Analytics: Average (or Weighted Average)
- Fantasy Football Analytics: Robust Average
- FantasyPros
- Yahoo
- FFtoday
- FantasySharks
- FantasyData
- ESPN
- CBS
- NFL.com
- WalterFootball
- FantasyFootballNerd
Notes: CBS estimates were averaged across Jamey Eisenberg and Dave Richard. FantasyFootballNerd projections include only their free projections (not their full subscription projections). We did not calculate the weighted average prior to 2015. The accuracy estimates may differ slightly from those provided in prior years because a) we now use standard league scoring settings (you can see the league scoring settings we used here) and b) we are only examining the following positions: QB, RB, WR, and TE. The weights for the weighted average were based on historical accuracy (1-MASE). For the analysts not included in the accuracy calculations, we calculated the average (1-MASE) value and subtracted 1/2 the standard deviation of (1-MASE). The weights in the weighted average for 2016 were:
CBS Average: .344
ESPN: .329
FantasyData: .428
FantasySharks: .327
FFToday: .379
NFL.com: .329
WalterFootball: .281
Yahoo Sports: .400
Here is a scatterplot of our average projections in relation to players’ actual fantasy points scored in 2016:
Interesting Observations
- Projections that combined multiple sources of projections (FFA Average, Weighted Average, Robust Average) were more accurate than all single sources of projections (e.g., CBS, NFL.com, ESPN) every year. This is consistent with the wisdom of the crowd.
- FFA projections were more accurate than projections from FantasyPros. This may be because we include more sources of projections.
- The simple average (mean) was more accurate than the robust average. The robust average gives extreme values less weight in the calculation of the average. This suggests that outliers may reflect meaningful sources of variance (i.e., they may help capture a player’s ceiling/floor) and may not just be bad projections (i.e., error/noise).
- The weighted average was equally accurate compared to the simple average. Weights were based on historical accuracy. If the best analysts are consistently more accurate than other analysts, the weighted average will likely outperform the mean. If, on the other hand, analysts don’t reliably outperform each other, the mean might be as or more accurate. Given the mean and weighted average were equally accurate each year, the evidence suggests that analysts don’t consistently outperform (or underperform) each other.
- The FFA Average explained 57–67% of the variation in players’ actual performance. That means that the projections are somewhat accurate but have much room for improvement in terms of prediction accuracy. 1/3 to 1/2 of the variance in actual points is unexplained by projections. Nevertheless, the projections are likely more accurate than pre-season rankings.
- The R-squared of the FFA average projection was .67 in 2012, .57 in 2013, .62 in 2014, .63 in 2015, and .65 in 2016. This suggests that players are more predictable in some years than others.
- There was little consistency in performance across time among sites that used single projections (CBS, NFL.com, ESPN). In 2012, CBS was the most accurate single source of projection but they were the least accurate in 2013. Moreover, ESPN was among the least accurate in 2014, but they were among the most accurate in 2015. This suggests that no single source reliably outperforms the others. While some sites may do better than others in any given year (because of fairly random variability–i.e., chance), it is unlikely that they will continue to outperform the other sites.
- Projections were more accurate for some positions than others. Projections were much more accurate for QBs and WRs than for RBs. Projections were the least accurate for Ks, DBs, and DSTs. For more info, see here. Here is how positions ranked in accuracy of their projections (from most to least accurate):
- QB: R2 = .73
- WR: R2 = .57
- TE: R2 = .55
- LB: R2 = .53
- RB: R2 = .48
- DL: R2 = .45
- K: R2 = .38
- DB: R2 = .37
- DST: R2 = .24
- Projections over-estimated players’ performance by about 4–10 points every year across most positions (based on mean error). It will be interesting to see if this pattern holds in future seasons. If it does, we could account for this over-expectation in players’ projections. In a future post, I hope to explore the types of players for whom this over-expectation occurs.
Conclusion
Fantasy Football Analytics had the most accurate projections over the last five years. Why? We average across sources. Combining sources of projections removes some of their individual judgment biases (error) and gives us a more accurate fantasy projection. No single source (CBS, NFL.com, ESPN) reliably outperformed the others or the crowd, suggesting that differences between them are likely due in large part to chance. In sum, crowd projections are more accurate than individuals’ judgments for fantasy football projections. People often like to “go with their gut” when picking players. That’s fine—fantasy football is a game. Do what is fun for you. But, crowd projections are the most reliably accurate of any source. Do with that what you will! But don’t take my word for it. Examine the accuracy yourself with our Projections tool and see what you find. And let us know if you find something interesting!
The post Who Has the Best Fantasy Football Projections? 2017 Update appeared first on Fantasy Football Analytics.
from Fantasy Football Analytics http://ift.tt/2nI5m49
via IFTTT
Saturday, March 18, 2017
NBA FanDuel Top 5 Plays For March 17th
NBA FanDuel Top 5 Plays for March 17th Happy St. Patrick’s Day to all of you! I decided to wait a little longer to get this out today so my article doesn’t get derailed by any news as it comes out during the day. Yesterday, I had a ton of LeBron before the news broke […]
NBA FanDuel Top 5 Plays For March 17th - Fantasy CPR - Fantasy CPR - A Fantasy Sports blog for news, rumors, and updates on all Fantasy Sports
from Fantasy Sports – Fantasy CPR http://ift.tt/2njOAe3
via IFTTT
Friday, March 17, 2017
DraftKings EPL DFS Soccer Premier League Picks – March 18 2017
Saturday brings us a full slate of Premier League games for DraftKings EPL DFS. There are 12 teams to pick from and we have you covered for tips, picks, analysis and lineups! Last week was a big cash in with Joshua King and the Everton stack helping us to 124.75 DraftKings points to finish in the […]
DraftKings EPL DFS Soccer Premier League Picks – March 18 2017 - Fantasy CPR - Fantasy CPR - A Fantasy Sports blog for news, rumors, and updates on all Fantasy Sports
from Fantasy Sports – Fantasy CPR http://ift.tt/2nNGl6y
via IFTTT
FanDuel EPL DFS Soccer Premier League Picks – March 18 2017
Another full slate for you this week with twelve Premier League teams going for it in FanDuel EPL action. Look no further for tips, picks and analysis for Saturday’s DFS! We had a strong showing last with top picks Joshua King and Michail Antonio going off for over 100 FanDuel points between them. A nice […]
FanDuel EPL DFS Soccer Premier League Picks – March 18 2017 - Fantasy CPR - Fantasy CPR - A Fantasy Sports blog for news, rumors, and updates on all Fantasy Sports
from Fantasy Sports – Fantasy CPR http://ift.tt/2mVree3
via IFTTT
Thursday, March 16, 2017
NBA FanDuel Top 5 Plays For March 16th
NBA FanDuel Top 5 Plays For March 16th Last night started bad and just got worse for my NBA FanDuel teams. DeMarcus “Boogie” Cousins got in early foul trouble, and never became a factor. He scored 31.3 FDP’s which didn’t come close to paying off his price. Nemanja Bjelica got hurt after scoring just 8.3 […]
NBA FanDuel Top 5 Plays For March 16th - Fantasy CPR - Fantasy CPR - A Fantasy Sports blog for news, rumors, and updates on all Fantasy Sports
from Fantasy Sports – Fantasy CPR http://ift.tt/2m43UvP
via IFTTT
Wednesday, March 15, 2017
Was DeAndre Hopkins Worth The 7th Pick?
Was DeAndre Hopkins Worth The 7th Pick? DeAndre Hopkins was typically taken 7th in Fantasy Football Drafts. Was DeAndre Hopkins worth the 7th pick? The Houston Texans wide receiver was coming into the season off of a very strong 2015 campaign. Hopkins was one of the Top 10 Non-QB’s in 2015, his 2016 campaign did […]
Was DeAndre Hopkins Worth The 7th Pick? - Fantasy CPR - Fantasy CPR - A Fantasy Sports blog for news, rumors, and updates on all Fantasy Sports
from Fantasy Sports – Fantasy CPR http://ift.tt/2mssuCH
via IFTTT